The Top 7 Sparkling Waters, Ranked

Two stints in college, a decade of (mostly) respectable publications, and this is what it comes to: Hi, everyone. Josh here. Today, I’ll be ranking the taste of seven unflavored waters.

Now, this isn’t as depressing as it sounds (or at least that’s what I’m choosing to tell myself). Seltzer water has seen a surge in popularity over the last few years, especially in the adult-beverage world. But we’re not here to debate the merits and cultural implications of White Claw. Instead, let’s focus on the most basic version of seltzer: Purified water, carbon dioxide, and maybe a stray mineral or two.

I’ve been drinking plain seltzer at an unreasonable pace for years, and I’ve come to the surprising conclusion that some unflavored versions somehow taste better than others. Read on for a ranking of seven of the most widely available brands of fizzy water, along with a breakdown of their relative cost per can.

Cost: $0.50 per 12-oz. can

This is the only entrant on the list with anything other than some form of “carbonated water” listed among its ingredients. Bubly adds a pair of chlorides, potassium and calcium, which have a noticeable effect on the flavor. Frankly, it’s not one I enjoy. This tastes like a can of Sprite with all the sugar and fruit sucked out. It persists on the palate as well, and can linger in the back of the throat. Add in the small 8-can packs and its vague tang, and this was the least pleasing pick of the bunch.

Cost: $0.56 per 12-oz. can

Polar and I are not friends. Look, the product itself is fine. There’s a noticeable smoothness here, with well-rounded bubbles and a more tannic sensation than some of the products ranked later. It’s kind of like someone mixed the ALDI and Kroger store brands in a glass and stirred the whole thing with a pool noodle dipped in chlorine. But here’s the thing I can’t stomach: At most of my local grocers, Polar recently swapped out its 12-packs for 8-packs, without much of a reduction in price—shrinkflation at work. That’s a 33% gouge to my fizzy water budget, and the flavor isn’t good enough to warrant this cost. Whether this is the fault of the producers or retailers, someone needs to go soak their shrinkflated head.

Cost: $0.37 per 12-oz. can

With the most aggressive carbonation of the bunch, Kroger’s store-brand seltzer feels a bit like having ants on your tongue. When I first tried this one, I wasn’t a fan. But as my recycling bin filled more and more quickly and the price of fizzy water went up, I made a conscious decision: I would force myself to enjoy these blue-camo cans. And it worked! I now look forward to the scouring burn, and it actually helps me drink the product more slowly. There’s a definite mouthfeel here, and a texture that’s lacking in Polar seltzer. Perhaps that texture comes from its highest in-test sodium, clocking in at 15 mg per can (1% of the recommended daily value). My shifting personal tastes have made this a favorite over a few of the lower ranked entries. But I don’t think its punchy seawater nature is for everyone.

Cost: $0.58 per 12-oz. can

LaCroix has, for the most part, held up as a seltzer option. As you’d expect from purified water, the flavor here is almost nonexistent. The texture is rather effervescent, disappearing off the tongue more quickly than most of the others. Still, there’s a touch more carbonation than you’ll find with Belle Vie (more on that later). There’s a reason LaCroix is so popular, with a drinking experience that’s as soft as the color and design of the can. I’m also going to award extra points for visibility, since it’s one of the easiest brands to find without lemon, grapefruit, or other additives. If it weren’t so damned expensive, my fridge might yet be full of LaCroix.

Cost: $1.27 per 12 oz.

I tried to find this stuff in cans but wound up with the classic green bottle instead; the unit price has been adjusted accordingly. San Pellegrino’s flavor and textural profiles are strikingly similar to the ALDI brand, and I can see why Italians love it. It should also be noted that this is one of three entries not to feature zeroes across its nutrition label: San Pellegrino and Perrier both feature 60 mg of calcium per 12 fluid ounces, which is in line with their standing as “mineral water.” But San Pellegrino also adds 10 mg of sodium to the mix, which perhaps explains its interesting taste. I could talk about the relative evils of Nestlé, but I’ll let you Google that topic for yourself. If you find yourself at an outdoor café with a plate of pasta before you, there are certainly worse things to drink.

Cost: $0.35 per 12-oz. can

The most economical pick of the litter just narrowly misses out on the top spot. Indeed, ALDI’s store brand is the undisputed champ around my house. The flavor of this flavorless liquid is beautiful: smooth, mild, and mouth-filling, with a perfect balance of carbonation. This stuff just tastes clean, and I could drink it by the gallon. It also helps that it comes in at about half the price of LaCroix. The only problem is its availability. In each ALDI store I’ve visited, pallets of Belle Vie are more or less parked on the sales floor, with their various flavors intermixed. It’s up to me, the consumer, to Jenga a few of these 12-packs out. But with a wonderful texture and price, I’m willing to put in the effort.

Cost: $1.37 per 12 oz.

Perrier was the last of the entrants I sampled. And yet, even with a belly full of water, the first sip came with an immediate realization: This feels the most like a beverage. Maybe it’s the green bottle (again, no cans in my area), or perhaps the connection of mental circuits. This was the first brand of seltzer I became familiar with, thanks to a series of crime novels by Lawrence Block. The protagonist, Matthew Scudder, is a private detective and recovering alcoholic who sips Perrier in place of bourbon. Regardless of my personal brain chemistry, though, the makeup of this liquid itself is pitch perfect. Its minerals and CO2 strike a balance between tannic and thirst quenching. Due to Perrier’s high cost and Nestlé ownership, I generally go with the ALDI Belle Vie fizzy water, but in a vacuum, Perrier still holds the crown.

Now, if you’ll excuse me, I have seven open containers of water on my table. Fortunately, my house plants are looking particularly thirsty.